Get The Pavlovic Today’s top stories and best reads.
Following inaccurate news reports on the explosion in NATO Member Poland, the Associated Press fired journalist James LaPorta.
The AP initially reported on November 15th that, according to an anonymous “senior US intelligence official,” the blast on Poland resulted from Russian missiles.
On the same day, the Polish and American governments concluded a Ukrainian air defense missile most likely caused the explosion. “There is nothing, absolutely nothing, to suggest that it was an intentional attack on Poland,” said the Polish President, Andrzej Duda, on November 16th.
National Security Council Spokesperson Adrienne Watson noted that the US had “seen nothing that contradicts President Duda’s preliminary assessment that this explosion was most likely the result of a Ukrainian air defense missile that unfortunately landed in Poland.”
“It is highly probable that it was fired by Ukrainian anti-aircraft defense” and “unfortunately fell on Polish territory,” reassured President Biden. As a result, AP issued a correction and James La Porta was fired.
What can journalism learn from this?
1. Fact-check your sources and do a close reading of statements
Journalists are required to provide a second source when sourcing is anonymous. LaPorta’s anonymous source informed him that the missiles that landed in Poland were Russian aircraft. However, instead of searching for a second source to confirm this claim, LaPorta filed the story citing only one anonymous source.
LaPorta’s false report could have generated a World War III scenario since his article implied that Russian aircraft landed on NATO territory, giving full permission for NATO Member States to trigger Articles 4 and 5.
It is an AP policy, as well as for most accredited news media outlets, to require more than one source when sourcing is anonymous.
Citing only one source, especially if it is a confidential one, could risk the integrity and validity of the information put forth by the report. Thus, it is ideal to reference at least two sources.
When reporting on delicate news, such as national and international security matters, journalist should make sure that the information gathered from secondary sources checks out with the statements of credible officials familiar with an investigation.
A close reading of officials’ statements is key to accurate reporting. They are valuable primary sources and should not be misinterpreted.
To avoid misinterpreting a primary source, a good reporter devotes their undivided attention to what is being communicated. Instead of reading a primary source statement with preconceived notions of what will be said, a successful journalist entirely focuses on what is being said in an official statement.
2. Anonymous sourcing needs to be vetted and justified
LaPorta did not explain why the interviewee had to be cited as a confidential source. Nonetheless, a reason for anonymity is always required according to AP policy.
Moreover, a confidential source needs to be approved by a news manager who knows the source’s identity.
In LaPorta’s case, the reporter used a confidential source that had been vetted for a previous story, but its use had not been approved for the piece on the Polish explosion.
Confidential sources have to be reasoned and approved by a supervisor before being cited in a story.
3. Include all perspectives
Even when following the protocol on anonymous sourcing, it is crucial to include statements from other institutions, whether if they contradict the interviewees or agree with them.
For example, while President Zelenskyy insisted that the attacks on Poland were authored by Russian officials, Biden and Duda were continuously contradicting the Ukrainian President by stating that the explosion was caused by Ukrainian air-defense misfire.
In this case, where the truth remains unclear, it is pivotal to include all diverging points of view from the parties involved in the situation.
EST9:00 AM President Biden receives the Presidential Daily Briefing 1:15 PM President Biden convenes a meeting of his Competition Council to receive an update on progress his Administration has made to increase competition in the American economy and lower prices for the American people3:15…Keep reading
The IMF has upgraded its forecasts for most leading economies and predicts global growth of 2.9%. However, the UK will be the only advanced economy to shrink this year by 0.6%. Even Russia, under sanctions, will perform better than the UK. “Growth in the United Kingdom is projected to be –0.6 percent in 2023, a 0.9 percentage…Keep reading
The meeting between House Speaker Kevin McCarthy and President Biden did not happen yet, but is already making a splash. The White House memo written by National Economic Council Director Brian Deese and Office of Management and Budget Director Shalanda Young ahead of the meeting on spending and the debt ceiling has caused a strong…Keep reading
more from the pavlovic today
President Biden exited at the residence at 10:06 am this morning on his way to Marine One. When asked what he would say to Speaker McCarthy when they meet on Wednesdays, Biden replied, “Show me your budget.” On his decision to end the COVID -19 emergency, Biden said it was extended until May 15, 2023.…Keep reading
President Biden’s meeting with McCarthy on Wednesday is going to be tense. According to the White House memo penned by National Economic Council Director Brian Deese and Office of Management and Budget Director Shalanda Young, the President intends to ask Speaker of the House Kevin McCarthy two questions. The first one will center on McCarthy’s…Keep reading
9:00 AM President Biden receives the Presidential Daily Briefing 10:05 AM President Biden departs the White House en route Joint Base Andrews 10:25 AM President Biden departs Joint Base Andrews en route Queens, New York 11:20 AM President Biden arrives in Queens, New York 11:30 AM President Biden departs en route New York, New York …Keep reading
Nadim Zahawi Attacks The Press Instead Of Taking Responsibility For The Violation Of The Ministerial Code
Instead of taking full responsibility for the breach of the Ministerial Code, Nadhim Zahawi launched an attack on the British press. Following Prime Minister’s Rishi Sunak investigation of Zahawi’s unpaid tax affairs, Sunak has fired his Conservative Party chairman. “It is clear that there has been a serious breach of the Ministerial Code. As a…Keep reading
Former UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson has stated in a BBC documentary that Russian President Vladimir Putin threatened to hurt him with a missile strike in a phone call before Russia’s brutal invasion of Ukraine. “A missile would only take a minute,” the former PM Boris Johnson claims Putin threatened him as a response to…Keep reading
EST 9:00 AM President Biden receives the Presidential Daily Briefing 12:50 PM President Biden departs New Castle, Delaware en route Baltimore, Maryland 1:25 PM President Biden arrives in Baltimore, Maryland 2:45 PM President Biden discusses how Bipartisan Infrastructure Law funding will replace the 150-year old Baltimore and…Keep reading