Photo: AdobeStock.com

Immigrations and Customs Enforcement announced on Monday that F1 and M1 visa holders — most international students — must leave the U.S. if their schools are online for the Fall semester. Students at schools with a hybrid model of reopening must take at least one in-person class or face deportation. 

As an international student, it is a terrifying time to be in the U.S. Stranded from friends and family back home, I am and will be on my own throughout this entire pandemic. With travel bans set in so many countries, including my own, the odds that I can fly home should cases spik, and my classes move online are slim. 

I am also not a citizen of my home country. My parents, who are divorced, are of different nationalities. I inherited my father’s passport and my mother’s tongue. 

If I face deportation in the U.S., I would have nowhere to go. 

This is my background and my own concerns with the new ICE policy. I am aware that the policy is more devastating for a lot of other students, those who are in the U.S. because they seek the freedom to be who they are. There are students who cannot go home due to fear of persecution: for their religion, their sexual orientation, or their political views. 

International students are not cash cows

Judging from the reaction online, the new ICE policy baffled everybody. Schools band together to sue for the reversal of the policy and students created petitions to protect their international community. 

While I find these actions necessary, and I am very thankful, I feel disheartened that the loudest reason to protect us, international students, is because we bring in money. 

The Association of American Universities, which represents 65 research universities, including my own, Columbia University, released a statement condemning policy on Tuesday. The policy will do “further damage to our nation’s universities, which are already struggling with unprecedented uncertainty, massive logistical complications, and significant financial losses due to the ongoing COVID-19 pandemic,” the statement reads. “This policy change would also have negative economic impact, because international students spend millions of dollars in our communities every year.”

I feel disheartened that the loudest reason to protect us, international students, is because we bring in money. 

The statement fails to mention all the other reasons why international students are necessary in the U.S., focusing solely on the $41 billion we bring to the economy. International students are at universities to contribute their intellect and curiosity. We bring in knowledge and perspective in all fields of academia.

 International students constitute a third of enrollment at science and engineering graduate schools. Imagine all the research, the pages written, the experiments conducted by these foreign students! In the arts and humanities, international students challenge what American high schools taught, bursting the bubble of American exceptionalism. We enrich the classroom debate. 

Outside these academic spaces, we form the community at the backbone of our institutions. To so many domestic students, we are friends verging on family. Our presence might mean the addition of dozens of new spices in the kitchen cabinet, or the tears on the floor after a night of binging a foreign TV series, or the promises of traveling the world together after graduation. 

Protect students, not money

What concerns me about the rhetoric used to protect international students is that it ignores the human beings we are. With money as the only reason why we should stay, schools and fellow students forget that we have passion and ambition and devotion. Everything we offer, undocumented students do as well.

The rhetoric used to protect international students is that it ignores the human beings we are.

This is what is most concerning about how we treat international students: it sets us apart from our undocumented peers when in fact, we are all students deserving of protection. When lawmakers prioritize money as what is most valuable, they invalidate the necessity of students who do not contribute as much to the economy. 

Undocumented students fought for their rights to remain in the U.S. for a long time. Their voices deserve amplification and their needs should be at the top of our demands in this ongoing fight against the new ICE policy.

more from the pavlovic today

Twitter Files: Elon Musk’s Access Journalism Club Of Only One

“Much ado about nothing,” Shakespeare used to say. The Twitter Files were expected to be a document drop, but Elon Musk quickly turned them into access for only one journalist. The chosen one, Matt Taibbi was given exclusive access to the files he then broke the story about, one tweet at a time. Clearly, he…

Keep reading

LIVE: Biden And Macron Hold A Joint Press Conference

French President Emmanuel Macron and his wife Brigitte arrived at 9:18 am at the White House were they were greeted by Joe and Jill Biden. This is the first state visit of Biden’s presidency. Macron was also the first state visit of the Trump presidency. And according to Carlos Elizondo, the White House social secretary,…

Keep reading

Biden’s schedule for December 1, 2022 is out

Today President Biden and Jill Biden will welcome French President Emmanuel Macron and Mrs. Brigitte Macron for a state visit. This will be the first state visit of Biden’s presidency. The President has a packed schedule. It includes an arrival ceremony, bilateral meeting, joint press conference, and state dinner. This will be President Macron’s second…

Keep reading

Inside The Downing Street England v Wales Match For MPs

On Tuesday evening, about 120 Conservative MPs flocked into No 10 to watch the England v Wales game. Inside, the flags of England and Wales were displayed on either side of the giant TV. Snacks and drinks were served. MPs stood and joined in singing the national anthem before the game. MPs representing English and…

Keep reading

Biden’s schedule for November 30, 2022 is out

EST 9:00 AM  President Biden receives the Presidential Daily Briefing                             11:05 AM President Biden departs the White House en route the White House Tribal Nations Summit11:30 AM  President Biden delivers remarks at the White House Tribal Nations Summit12:15 PM President Biden  departs the White House Tribal Nations Summit en route the White House                            12:20 PM President Biden arrives at the White House 5:30 PM The First…

Keep reading

Candy Chan

Candy Chan is studying History with a focus on War and Revolution at Barnard College. She is currently a staff writer at the Columbia Daily Spectator, covering issues pertaining to Columbia's...

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *