Donald Trump can dress it up any way he likes. He can summon the spin doctors, rearrange the political furniture and insist that the whole midterms catastrophe was merely “one of those things.” But it wasn’t.
For all practical purposes, Donald Trump’s presidency effectively ended on Election Night.
And before conservatives rush to say that Trump is a fighter, that he has come back before and that he will somehow fight his way back again, this time the arithmetic is different. There is no electoral comeback available to him. There is only the cliff edge of a final two years in office with Democrats controlling both chambers of Congress.
Some of his current loyalists may soon decide that the grass looks greener elsewhere. After all, politics is ultimately about survival, and the Republican Party is already beginning to think about life after Trump.
The man who returned to the White House promising to make America great again has managed, in just two years, to hand Washington back to the Democrats. Not one chamber of Congress, but both. And with that, the political machinery on which his second presidency depended has come crashing down.
Vice President JD Vance has already produced a lengthy diagnosis of the Republican defeat. There will doubtless be more memos, more explanations and considerably more finger-pointing.
But the truth is simpler.
The war in Iran, the failure to bring down the cost of living and voters’ concerns about corruption helped drive the Republican collapse. Trump himself has acknowledged that Iran played a role. Vance went considerably further, arguing that the war was central to the defeat.
Trump promised relief on Day One. Americans are still waiting.
The political ground for Republicans had been shifting for some time. The murder of Charlie Kirk shook the conservative movement and deprived it of one of its most effective organizers. However, it did not change the fundamental question confronting the Republican Party: What, exactly, had become of the movement that brought Trump back to power?
The voters who delivered his comeback were not all clamoring for another war in the Middle East. They wanted lower prices, economic security and a president who would put their interests first.
Instead, many found themselves watching a presidency increasingly consumed by foreign conflict, internal rivalries and allegations that political proximity had become a route to private profit.
And Trump, as ever, was magnificently overconfident.
Once again, he assembled an administration straight from what he likes to call central casting. There were familiar faces, television personalities and political loyalists. But looking the part and being capable of governing are two entirely different things.
The greatest miscalculation of Trump’s second political act, however, may have been his ruthless decision to kick Ron DeSantis to the curb.
Trump mocked him, diminished him and made certain that there could be only one star in the MAGA solar system.
He did not succeed.
While Republicans were being swept out of power across much of the country, Florida remained in Republican hands. Byron Donalds won the governorship. Ashley Moody held the Senate seat. The Republican machine DeSantis helped build did not collapse simply because the national party did.
That does not mean Florida escaped the Democratic wave entirely. Republican redistricting ambitions fell short, and several Democratic House candidates survived in districts the GOP had hoped to capture.
But DeSantis has demonstrated that conservative political power can exist beyond Trump’s personal fortunes.
He also comes to this moment with something increasingly valuable in Republican politics: a governing record that has not been swallowed by the scandals now consuming parts of Trump’s inner circle.
DeSantis is a Yale-educated lawyer, a former congressman and a two-term governor. He has not become embroiled in the kind of $50 million legal-services controversy now surrounding Alina Habba.
At a time when questions about public office, private money and political access have become politically poisonous, DeSantis offers Republicans a very different proposition. Conservative values and principles.
After spending years trying to destroy DeSantis, Trump has left open the possibility of bringing him into his administration once the governor leaves office.
If DeSantis is wise, he should consider very carefully what that invitation would actually offer him. Why climb aboard a ship taking on water when you could be preparing to captain the next one?
With the end of 2026 approaching, Trump has barely two months to push whatever remains of his legislative ambitions through a Republican-controlled Congress.
Come January, the rules of Washington change.
He may become, as he has already suggested, “Mr. Veto.” But a veto is not a governing program.
Trump can also try to do something that has never come naturally to him. Negotiate with Democrats.
The alternative is two years of political trench warfare, with a president barricaded inside the White House, veto pen in hand, while his opponents control Capitol Hill.
There is something strikingly familiar about this Republican disaster.
What happened to the Republicans in America is what happened to the Conservative Party in Britain.
The Conservatives discovered that no amount of patriotic rhetoric, personality politics or promises of national renewal could compensate for the exhaustion of public trust.
The Republicans have now received their own version of that message.
Enough.
Trump was given something very few politicians receive: a second chance to get it right. He returned to the presidency with a mandate, a Republican Congress and an extraordinary opportunity to demonstrate that the lessons of his first administration had been learned.
Instead, he repeated many of the same habits, this time with even greater confidence and considerably higher stakes. And Americans delivered their verdict.
The question is no longer whether Trump can dominate the Republican Party. The question is whether the Republican Party can survive being dominated by Trump.
American conservatism needs a new leader.
That is where DeSantis comes back into the picture. The man Trump tried to destroy could turn out to be the man who resurrects the Republican Party.
related
Trump Stays Neutral as Scalise and Jordan Battle for House GOP
President Donald Trump is staying out of the battle to replace House Speaker Mike Johnson as the Republican leader in the next Congress. Asked Wednesday whether he was endorsing…
‘Oh, What a Night!’ Schumer Takes a Victory Lap and Promises Investigations
The morning after election night, Sen. Chuck Schumer was in a very good mood. Democrats had won back the Senate, and even Schumer had not expected a majority of…
Hakeem Jeffries and Chuck Schumer Take Washington
It was the election night Donald Trump and his inner circle had hoped would never come. Republicans lost the House. They lost the Senate. And now to political leaders…
